Share Link: https://bit.ly/UUstatementBAAJA
Rooted in Justice, against the deregulation in Permitting Reform
On behalf of Unitarian Universalists of faith and conscience, we oppose the version of Permitting Reform being advanced in Congress as S. 5653, the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) of 2026. It fails to align with our faith teachings and values that call us to hold in love our recognition of interdependence, our need for justice, and our commitment to equity. We find the current proposal favors industry interests over the needs of people, communities, and ecosystems. It perpetuates the structural injustices of environmental racism and strikes at the foundations of the environmental policies that keep our communities safe from corporations more concerned with profit than people and planet. The bill sacrifices the sovereign rights and interests of Indigenous communities, as well as the preservation of sacred and cultural resources, at a time when the climate crisis is already forcing another generation of people from their homes. BAAJA runs counter to decades of Unitarian Universalist Social Witness statements: instead, we say, “But let justice roll down like waters, and righteousness like an ever-flowing stream” (Amos 5:24).
BAAJA shifts away from permitting solutions that respect community needs, democracy, transparency, accountability, and environmental protections. Instead, it functions as a deregulatory push that prioritizes shareholder interests while jeopardizing community agency and prioritizing corporate interests. It locks in fossil fuel use, in exchange for transmission expansion, at the cost of community health and the legal tools impacted communities use to hold industry accountable. The trade-offs are too steep a price.
The American people have seen too many rollbacks of environmental policy, science, and programs to now surrender our right to the democratic process as a safeguard for our communities. Further hobbling the Clean Water Act (CWA), the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA), and the Endangered Species Act (ESA) should make this deal null and void. It limits environmental reviews and community and Tribal input. It lets data center developers avoid federal permitting and undermine accountability by targeting expansion within U.S. gas basins; it may trigger Section 404 CWA liabilities, which also apply when a data center is built on private lands (which most are). It imposes unrealistic and unreasonable timelines for input and judicial review. It disallows the introduction of new data, research, or insight. Our evidence-based understandings from developing the endangerment finding and cataloging disproportionate impacts should preclude this course of action. The ways this bill erodes democracy alone should render this dead on arrival. The project certainty feature makes it very difficult for future administrations to revisit permitting decisions based on new policies, health or environmental impact data, economic projections, or for any other legitimate policy reasons. This blocks us from acting in accordance with our conscience and responsibility to rectify harm, which undermines the sacred relational foundations of Unitarian Universalism.
This deregulatory push shows how structural racism manifests as federal policy violence; this is clear if we remember that we, as Unitarian Universalists, stated in 1970: “The thrust of continental policy is now, as it has been historically, the steady expropriation of Indian land and water resources for the benefit of whites in the United States.” In 2021, we reasserted that “Systemic white supremacy is a direct affront to every one of our principles.”
We also know that environmental racism violates the Civil Rights Act. A justice analysis that has been affirmed in foundational documents such as The 17 Principles of Environmental Justice (1991) and The Jemez Principles for Democratic Organizing (1996). Our faithful friends in the United Church of Christ said it directly in their 1987 landmark report, Toxic Wastes and Race in the United States: A National Report on the Racial and Socio-Economic Characteristics of Communities with Hazardous Waste Sites, when they agreed with the National Council of Churches: “Racism is more than just a personal attitude; it is the institutionalized form of that attitude.”
BAAJA perpetuates sacrifice zones and sacrifice constituencies, discarding the inherent worth and dignity of the very communities whom legislators continue to abandon. Poor Black, Indigenous, and people of color (BIPOC) and white folks in urban and rural communities will bear the disproportionate impacts of “progress” for the sake of net gains in emission reductions.
We love our neighbors too much to accept that abundance is dictated through racist and classist policy. Structural and environmental racism is fundamentally unholy, and an affront to our sacred and radically inclusive Love. We refute the notion that people near point-source pollution, or who will see their cherished lands strip-mined and despoiled, must bear the multigenerational costs while the fossil fuels industry is maintained through corporate welfare.
Since 1967, Unitarian Universalists have aligned with Tribal nations against continued encroachment on their lands for resources, including renewable energy. Our opposition to BAAJA, on Indigenous Sovereignty grounds, is aligned with at least 59 years of UU precedent. BAAJA threatens Tribal sovereignty by undermining Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act (NHPA), a critical tool that ensures that Tribes can weigh in on federal decisions that would affect sacred sites and historic properties. Section 106 requires consultation with Tribes/Nation before the start of any project that could potentially impact protected sites. BAAJA states agencies “may” consult with Tribes/Nations after the review is complete and any report is issued, meaning that Tribes/Nations will have less input on decisions impacting their sacred sites. The challenge to the Section 106 process, and thus our obligations to Tribal Nations, should make this a non-starter. As Unitarian Universalists, we must not sacrifice Tribal communities in our country’s pursuit of energy infrastructure. The need to take action in the promotion of all rights of Indigenous peoples is imperative to the future of humankind.
Our faith calls us into a deeper LOVE in our free search for responsible truth that embraces a generous and transformative pluralism. This deeper love fundamentally demands interdependence, equity, and justice. We would much rather see Congress start with proposals such as the Environmental Justice for All Act, using that as a baseline for addressing climate change, the climate crisis, and environmental harms. From that posture, Congress can then address rising energy costs, the need to expand cleaner energy, and the public sector’s capacity deficit in managing permits. Perhaps reconsider and improve measures such as the Clean Electricity and Transmission Acceleration Act, the Cheap Energy Act, and the Energy Bills Relief Act.
We want Congress to move our economy and society toward a thriving future in strategic and practical ways that improve technology and our built environment while preserving our public lands and community agency or sovereignty. We seek a wholeness with justice. Let all people of faith and conscience reject complicity with domination and instead live into the courageous call to love every neighbor. No community, species, or ecosystem should be sacrificed for net emissions reductions. Accepting BAAJA would make us complicit in harm to the very lives we hold sacred.
If BAAJA proponents were serious about the permitting process without sacrificing communities, their proposal would invest in agency staff and capacity while also incentivizing industry to bring forward permit-ready, shovel-ready plans: project concepts that have undergone meaningful community consultation and undertakings that have won authentic consent to proceed. Instead, BAAJA pursues speed and backlog clearance via strict procedural timelines, legal overhauls, and structural limitations on environmental reviews.
Unfortunately, BAAJA does not move in a productive direction; instead, it further jeopardizes bedrock environmental laws; surrenders meaningful environmental review; imperils Tribal sovereignty and heritage rights; expedites and entrenches the fossil fuel industry; grants foreign mining conglomerates access to public lands; muddles clean water and ocean protections; gives developers and polluters privileged access to courts; imposes strict statutes of limitations; and weakens protections for endangered species. Overall, it shows we have not learned from nearly 100 years of privileging the fossil fuels industry and corporate actors over people and our communities. Across the board, it shows once again that Congress is all too willing to ignore nearly certain harm to communities for the prospect of profits and net gains.
As a faith tradition, we, Unitarian Universalists, call Congress back into fellowship, caring for our communities, and covenant with our interdependent web of life. We ask Congress to set this permitting reform – deregulation push – proposal aside and work toward measures that ensure environmental justice, honor Tribal consultation obligations and rights, preserve creation, and then structure human activity and procedures toward sustainability. We counsel Congressional policy staff to start with frameworks such as the Environmental Justice for All Act, and we commit to help them pass it. We conclude that the altars of progress, affordability, and profit should not require sacrifice of community input, accountability, or fact-based science.
Unitarian Universalists have long understood ourselves as bearers of love and justice in the world, those who show up for peace and freedom, who side with love in the face of all that would otherwise diminish our humanity. Love only exists in relationship to the beloved. Love does not happen all alone. Love, fundamentally, calls us into accountable relations with all our human and beyond-human beloveds.
Therefore, we call on our Unitarian Universalist community to actively oppose the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026. Join with others, both interfaith and secular allies, in that work. Trust that Congress can do better when it follows robust community consultation and crafts legislation in a transparent process. Believe that we can succeed in demanding better of our national legislators.
We cry together, in one unified voice, “May it be so.”
List of joiners*:
- Diverse Revolutionary Unitarian Universalist Multicultural Ministries
- JUUstice Washington
- Maine Unitarian Universalist State Action Network
- MUUSJA – Minnesota Unitarian Universalist Social Justice Alliance
- New York Unitarian Universalist Justice
- Oregon Unitarian Universalist Voices for Justice
- Tennessee Unitarian Universalist Community Action Network
- Texas Unitarian Universalist Justice Ministry
- Unitarian Universalist Action New Hampshire
- Unitarian Universalist Advocacy Network of Illinois
- Unitarian Universalist Animal Ministry
- Unitarian Universalist Association
- Unitarian Universalist Colorado Action Network (UUCAN)
- Unitarian Universalist FaithAction NJ
- Unitarian Universalist Justice Ministry of North Carolina
- Unitarian Universalist Legislative Ministry of Maryland
- Unitarian Universalist Massachusetts Action Network
- Unitarian Universalist Ministers Association
- Unitarian Universalist Ministry for Earth
- Unitarian Universalist Service Committee
- Unitarian Universalists for Just Economic Community
- Unitarian Universalists for Social Justice
- UU Justice Florida (UUJF)
- Unitarian Universalist Justice Ministry of CA
- Unitarian Universalist Women’s Federation
- UUJusticePA
- Virginia Unitarian Universalist State Action Network
- Wisconsin Unitarian Universalist State Action Network
****If your UU Organization would like to join, proceed here.
Related Resources and Statements:
UUA Items:
- The American Indian | 1967 General Resolution
- Indian Rights | 1970 Business Resolution
- Justice for Indigenous Peoples | 1993 General Resolution
- Environmental Justice | 1994 General Resolution
- Solidarity with the San Carlos Apache Regarding Mt. Graham | 1997 Action of Immediate Witness
- Earth, Air, Water, and Fire | 1997 General Resolution
- In Support of America’s Red Rock Wilderness Act | 2009 Action of Immediate Witness
- The Green Revolution in Religion | 2010 Business Resolution
- Sacred Roots: Indigenous Rights, Resistance and Reclamation | 2014 UU United Nations Office Intergenerational Seminar Statement
- Support a Strong, Compassionate Global Climate Agreement in 2015: Act for a Livable Climate | 2015 Action of Immediate Witness
- We Are All Related: Solidarity NOW with Indigenous Water Protectors | 2018 Action of Immediate Witness
- Address 400 Years of White Supremacist Colonialism | 2020 Action of Immediate Witness
- Undoing Systemic White Supremacy: A Call to Prophetic Action | 2021 Statement of Conscience
- World on Fire: Humanitarian Work and Climate Change | 2024 Action of Immediate Witness
- UUA President: 2025 Statement on Endangerment Finding
- Defend Against the Assault on Environmental Protections: Public Lands Rules and the Endangerment Finding | 2026 Action of Immediate Witness
Non-UU items:
- BAAJA & Project 2025: BAAJA-
Project-2025-factsheet-FINAL- footnotes.pdf - Eric Pica, President, FOE: “We are witnessing political malpractice by Sens. Whitehouse and Heinrich of the highest order as we barrel to a vote on permitting reform next week.”
- The End of the Environmental Era by Ariel Moger, Public Affairs Director, FOE
- National Association of Tribal Historic Preservation Officers, NATHPO Opposes Permitting Bill, the Bill Represents a Legislative Assault on the Sovereignty of Tribal Nations
- National Congress of American Indians: Joint Statement on Protecting Section 106 Process of NHPA, and NCAI Joined Tribal Organizations Across Indian Country in calling on Congress to Withdraw Title III of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA)
- The Climate Justice Alliance (CJA), WE ACT for Environmental Justice, the Western Environmental Law Center (WELC), and the Indigenous Environmental Network: Broad Coalition Demands Affordable, Safe Energy, Rejects Polluter-Driven Permitting Reform.
- Factsheet on BAAJA’s Modeling, Center for Biological Diversity and Oil Change International
- How the BAAJA Could Unlock a Massive Expansion of Data Center-Linked Gas Infrastructure, Oil Change International
- BAAJA Will Accelerate the Expansion of Deadly Immigration Detention Facilities, Detention Watch Network
- Senate Bipartisan Permit Reform Bill Would Upend Many Environmental Laws, Michael B. Gerrard, Sabin Center for Climate Change Law, Columbia Law School
- Food and Water Watch: Bipartisan Permitting Reform Plan is Danger to Public Health, Enviro Protection, States’ Rights
- ACLU: ACLU analysis says BAAJA would Accelerate ICE’s Expansion of Deadly, Dangerous Detention Centers
- Oil Change International: A Blatant Giveaway to Big Oil and Big Tech: Oil Change International Opposes Potential Permitting Bill
- Center for Biological Diversity: Legislation Would Dismantle Protections for Hundreds of Endangered Species to Speed Approvals for Corporate Polluters
- Western Environmental Law Center: Five-alarm fire: Radical Senate ‘permitting reform’ bill threatens to eviscerate environmental, wildlife, water, climate laws
- Friends of the Earth Action: ‘Permitting Reform’ Deal Hurts Animals, People, and the Environment
- Conservation Law Foundation: Senate’s Backroom Energy Deal Puts Communities and Clean Energy at Risk
- Southern Environmental Law Center: “Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act” would roll back environmental protections for communities
- Green Latinos: GreenLatinos Condemns Permitting Deal That Weakens Community and Environmental Protections
- Sierra Club: Reaction to Permitting Bill Introduction
- League of Conservation Voters: Statement on Senate Permitting Deal
- Natural Resources Defense Council: Permitting Bill: “Desperately Needed” But Must Improve
- New York Communities For Change: Stop the Data Center/AI and Oil & Gas Company Power Grab: Oppose the Latest Version of a Federal Permitting Deal
